Vegan Cheddar Cheese Spread

Ginny McMeans

Ginny McMeans

Published:

June 6, 2015

Last Modified:

May 8, 2024

Vegan Cheddar Cheese Spread is simple and versatile. The sharp flavor of cheddar but no dairy! Use it in casseroles, on tacos, and even as a dip.

Alternative Cheddar Cheese spread in a white bowl against a black background and cashews spread around.

This recipe comes in so handy so often. Thank goodness it is easy to make.

You do have to soak the cashews, but luckily, that doesn’t take any tending to.

So many times I am trying to think of a casserole to make and, gosh darn it, every time it needs a sauce or spread as one of the layers.

It became my mission to create some delicious cheesy-type spreads that I could use to expand my horizons.

Well, this Cashew Cheddar Cheese Spread is so delicious that you’ll want to eat it with a spoon.

Vegan Mozzarella is swirled and piled high in a silverplate sugar cup with a spoon on the side for spreading.

I love this vegan cheddar cheese because it is so versatile. Layer it inside macaroni casseroles, use it in burritos, or on tacos. It is even a great dip.

Should you soak cashews

  • I used to soak them for every milk and cheese recipe.
  • Sometimes, I’d soak for an hour, sometimes overnight.
  • You can even soak raw or roasted cashews.  It makes them softer for blending to a smooth consistency.
  • If you’re making milk, no residue is left over like in almonds.  They disappear into the recipe.
  • If you have a super-powerful blender you don’t need to soak cashews.  But it doesn’t hurt to soak them.
  • I have soaked the cashews for one hour for this recipe and the spread/sauce/sip is creamy.
  • So you can see that it doesn’t matter but if the recipe tells me to soak them – go ahead and do it.  It may make a difference for their recipe.

I think I’ve already pointed out a couple of times how versatile this recipe is. The flavors are delicious and the actual making of the vegan cheddar cheese is just minutes.

You can spread it in pita bread along with mung bean sprouts and all your favorite veggies.

Check it out! And don’t miss out on checking out two more homemade everyday necessities below the recipe card.

Square photos of a spread in a white bowl against a black background and cashews spread around.

Ingredients

  • Raw cashews a mild in taste and make a wonderful flavor base to build alternative cheeses.
  • Water adds needed liquid for blending.
  • Nutritional yeast has a wonderful cheesy type of flavor.
  • Lemon juice just a little bit to add a tangy flavor.
  • Dijon mustard is a mildly sharp flavor that enhances the ‘cheese’.
  • Garlic powder goes a long way in the flavor department with just a little bit.
  • Salt is an important flavor for seasoning.
  • Ground black pepper is very spicy so don’t use a lot.

Instructions

  • If you don’t have a powerful blender then soak the cashews. Cover the cashews in a large container by about 2″ with water. Let soak for about an hour and then drain.
  • You can get a smooth texture with cashews. Place all ingredients in a blender and blend until it is smooth and creamy.
  • Give it a taste but I don’t think you’ll need any adjustments in seasonings.
  • You can store the spread for about 1 week in the refrigerator.
  • The spread freezes really well too so split it in half and freeze for the future.

How to freeze vegan cheddar

  • IF FREEZING:
  • Pack in a hard-sided freezer container with a tight-fitting lid.
  • TO PREPARE AFTER FREEZING:  
  • Put in the fridge the day before using. Stir and use in any manner that you like.

Vegan condiment in a white bowl with a jar of cashews behind and scattered on the mat.

Cashew Cheddar Cheese Spread

Ginny McMeans
5 from 3 votes
Cashew Cheddar Cheese Spread is simple and versatile.
Prep Time 15 minutes
Soaking Time 1 hour
Total Time 15 minutes
Servings 24 Ounces

Want to save this recipe to your email?

Ingredients
  

  • 2 cups raw cashews
  • 1/2 cup water – to add to the mixture in the blender or food processor.
  • 1/2 cup nutritional yeast
  • 1/4 cup lemon juice
  • 2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
  • 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon sea salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground black pepper

Instructions
 

  • Cover the cashews in a large container by about 2" with water. Let soak for about an hour and then drain.
  • Place all ingredients into a blender and blend until it is smooth and creamy.
  • Just wait until you taste it!
  • The spread will keep in the refrigerator for about 1 week.
  • You can also freeze it.

Nutrition

Serving:4Ounces, Calories:63kcal, Carbohydrates:3g, Protein:2g, Fat:4g, Sodium:54mg, Potassium:91mg, Vitamin C:1.1mg, Calcium:4mg, Iron:0.8mg

share this recipe

21 responses to “Vegan Cheddar Cheese Spread”

5 from 3 votes (1 rating without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




  1. Martha @ A Family Feast Avatar

    This looks so creamy – and I’m just imagining the flavors!

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      That s great and thanks so much Martha!

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      Thanks so much Stephanie!

  2. Lora @cakeduchess Avatar

    What a fun way to have that cheese flavor when you’re trying to cut back or for those that can’t have cheese in their diet. Great job can’t wait to see the mozzarella version!

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      You’re the best Lora. Thanks so much!

  3. The Food Hunter Avatar

    very interesting…I’d try it.

  4. Cookin Canuck Avatar

    What a great sauce to have on hand for casseroles! I’m also amazed at your ability to make almost anything vegan.

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      Love ya Cookin Canuck! You make me smile – big!

  5. Rose | The Clean Dish Avatar

    Cashews are so versatile! Adding nutritional yeast definitely makes it cheesy. I love this recipe!!

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      I love cashews Rose. It seems you can do anything with them. Thanks so much!

  6. Amanda @ The Kitcheneer Avatar

    I am finding that you can be so creative with cashews! Can’t wait to try this one!

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      Fantastic Amanda! Thanks so much 🙂

  7. Angie | Big Bear's Wife Avatar

    Ooo I love your idea to use this in macaroni casseroles!! I bet it would be fantastic in that!

  8. Melanie Avatar

    I adore cashews. Never thought to try this combo but it sounds wonderful. Your pictures sell it for sure!

  9. Suzy Avatar
    Suzy

    5 stars
    This was so easy to make and it really added to the taco casserole that I made. Just a little spread was between the tortilla layers and it made the whole dish.

  10. Herb Avatar
    Herb

    So do I use the water (1/2c) to soak the cashews or is that water for the recipe to put in the blender\food processor?

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      Hi Herb! That 1/2 cup water is to be added to the blender/food processor. I made the instructions clearer and thanks for your question.

  11. Melissa Avatar
    Melissa

    I wonder if you could add some cooked carrot to give it a bit of an orange colour?

    1. Ginny McMeans Avatar

      You could Melissa but it would also make it a bit sweeter. I think the better option would be to add a very orange sweet potato. Not one of the white skinned ones and it wouldn’t be quite as sweet.

  12. Starrysky Avatar
    Starrysky

    5 stars
    Hello,
    Love this recipe! I did modify s bit, using only 3 Tablespoons of Nutritional Yeast, added 1/4 or 1/2 Tsp Onion Powder, a tiny pinch of Tumeric, and used 1/4 Tsp White Pepper, and a pinch of ground Black Pepper. Frroze some in silicone butter molds and 1 square block mold (similar sized cream cheese block) and used the freshly made in a Pasta Bean Salad and now trying with Cooked Pasta. You did a great job on this one with on-hand ingredients! This is a keeper and will use it all the time. Going to try your Vegan Mozzarella that can be sliced. I use another recipe Cashew Dill Mozzarella but not for slicing. I always soak my cashews overnight even though I have a High Speed Blendtec Blender. Thanks & Blessings,

Ginny McMeans

Ginny McMeans

Hi, my name is Ginny and it is fantastic that you have come to visit and see my recipes. I have a positive attitude and can’t seem to be in nature enough. My North American bird count is 678 and I’m always watching for mammals and insects too. My head is stuffed full of recipes that I want to create and life is just to dang short. The recipes feature healthy and delicious vegan food that you can enjoy now or freeze for future meals.

Follow on social media:
More about Ginny